I have attempted two soups in my life: Potato Soup (which was amazing) and Onion Soup (which was a complete and utter disaster. Tasted like dirt and grass soup). So, I'm currently 1-1 with soups.
This is the TASTY video I saved on Facebook for French Onion Soup.
I sort of followed these instructions, but I wanted it to be very delicious and also very easy and, for some reason, I started this while feeling very pretentious about the quality of the soup and didn't see some things in this particular recipe that I was sure should be included. So, I did a little research and combined a few recipes to make my own inclusive version. Mostly one that included Gruyere. What is this Swiss and Parmesan nonsense?!?
It turned out pretty flipping amazing actually. I just had my first bite. I think I picked up a cold from one of the children I work with, and I am certain this soup will heal my soul.
![]() |
| The Finished Decadence artfully displayed on coaster on paper plate. |
FRENCH ONION SOUP
- 2 large sweet onions
- 4 tbsp butter
- salt (to taste)
- pepper (to taste)
- 1/2 tsp sugar
- apple cider vinegar (like, 1/8 c? I had a little in the bottom of a bottle)
- worchestershire (however much you deem appropriate)
- 1/2 tsp ground sage
- garlic (I used about 4-5 cloves, you can use however much you want, or none)
- 6 cups beef broth
- 1 bay leaf
- white wine (I used 2 miniature Sutter Home Pinot Grigio, enough to cover the onions)
- cognac (I used 1 miniature Hennesey VS)
- a baguette cut in little rounds
- GRUYERE cheese (about 8 oz. shredded)
As you can see, my ingredients varied from what was in the video, but not by much. Also, I did not use a ceramic soup bowl or any little ramekins. I made do with what I had, like a true middle class American.
WHAT I DID:
![]() |
| I used a deep stainless steel skillet the whole time. It was perfect. |
I melted the butter and then threw in 6 cups of these bad boys. I moved them around a lot in the beginning until they were all covered in butter because I didn't want to stress about them. Then I had to leave them alone. That was hard for me until I realized I forgot to get wine and cognac. Because I had to go and get those, not watching the onions became easier. I left them on low and headed out.
When I came back, they looked like this. Perfect.
![]() |
| Easily the #1 MVP of this recipe besides the cognac |
![]() |
| Starting to look like a real French Onion Soup |
I also remembered the cognac at about this point and had to open the bottle with my teeth in order to get it in the soup.
I had some garlic bits left on the cutting board, so I added those on top of the baguette rounds I had already sliced up and covered in olive oil. It turned out okay. The garlic got a bit browner than I would have liked, but I was also rushing it at the end and turned the oven temp up from 325 to 350 and wasn't paying very close attention. I cooked them appx. 10 minutes on each side. To be fair, I think it was 12 on one side and about 6 on the other. Like I said, hungry.
While the baguette rounds were crisping up, I just left the soup up top to simmer and combine. I occasionally removed the lid to taste it because I was getting so very hungry and impatient at this point. I decided to forgo any of this "baking the soup" in the oven until I had it in a bowl.
![]() |
| You can see the extra brown garlic on top. Oops. It still tasted fine though. No burned flavors. |
![]() |
| Gruyere: Swiss' elegant and perfect cousin. |
![]() |
| Impatiently peeking at the progress with my mouth watering and fingers crossed. |
![]() |
| Heaven in a bowl. |
_________________________________________________________________________________
FRENCH ONION SOUP GRADING
Time Involved (Prep): A
Time Involved (Cooking): B-
Ease of Recipe Ingredients: A-
Dishes Involved: A-
Flavor: A+
Satisfaction: A+
The onions were the most difficult part of this recipe and they weren't even really difficult, just time consuming. I think I could have dealt with the onions taking so long if I didn't feel compelled to babysit them. Maybe if I make it a few more times, I can just feel confident they will be alright and go do other things. I did start this around 6:30 pm and was eating at 8 pm, so it wasn't terrible, it just felt long.
_________________________________________________________________________________
Anyway, time to eat and cuddle my cat and watch the Olympics. Thank goodness for the Olympics.









